Accounting & Finance

Lessons from the demise of Zillow’s iBuying business

  • 3 min Read
  • December 3, 2021

Author

Kanika Sinha
Kanika Sinha

Kanika is an enthusiastic content writer who craves to push the boundaries and explore uncharted territories. With her exceptional writing skills and in-depth knowledge of business-to-business dynamics, she creates compelling narratives that help businesses achieve tangible ROI. When not hunched over the keyboard, you can find her sweating it out in the gym, or indulging in a marathon of adorable movies with her young son.

Online real estate marketplace Zillow recently announced the closure of its iBuying business and that it would lay off about 25% of its staff, or approximately 2,000 employees, as a result of its exit from the home-buying market.


Unfortunately, the news came as no surprise to observers who deemed Zillow’s instant buying model for real estate unsustainable. They say the iBuying program attempted to cut the essential element out of the home buying and selling process: human interaction.


Why did Zillow shutter its home-buying business?



The story began in 2018, when Zillow got into the then-fledgling iBuying business. The iBuying model entails purchasing homes directly from sellers and then reselling them for a profit after doing renovations and other minor repairs. 


With iBuying, an instant all-cash offer is generated for the home based on property data that gets crunched through AI-powered algorithms and machine learning. It allows homeowners to sell their homes without the need for open houses or staging.


Zillow had bet big on this strategy. But the company bungled its iBuyer program by removing estate agents, brokerages and other professionals from the process altogether. Instead of improving the home buying process, Zillow ended up showing how hard it is to use AI to value real estate. 


After tallying about $1 billion in losses in about 3.5 years, Zillow decided to shutter its iBuying program. The move has implications not just for the real estate industry, but for other industries as well.


Business learnings



Zillow’s experience offers insights for businesses seeking to leverage technologies such as AI and automation to stay competitive in an evolving marketplace. In the rush to embrace technology to reduce overhead — for example, by getting rid of physical storefronts and replacing salespeople with AI bots or algorithms — removing the human touch could derail businesses. 


The collapse of Zillow’s iBuying program shows the downside of relying too much on automation and algorithms. Swayed by the potential of big data and AI to simplify expensive, real-world decisions, Zillow’s leaders focused on the market to the exclusion of focusing on clients. 


But the real estate business (and most other businesses) require relationships to run smoothly. Trust among real estate agents, buyers and sellers is essential and can’t be driven only by numbers. Human connection and emotion is what leads buyers into the homes of their dreams and what helps sellers fetch a better price. An algorithm is no substitute for a knowledgeable agent with expertise in the local real estate market.


Indeed, human interaction remains an essential element of conducting most businesses and this cannot be conveyed through a screen, no matter how advanced the technology is. 


Takeaway



At its best, technology is a tool that facilitates consumer transactions while also bringing out the best in people. But it cannot completely own the transaction and cast off any human that is already part of the space, whether it pertains to real estate or any other industry. Short-sighted attempts to replace meaningful in-person interactions, or to completely remove the human element altogether, will likely hurt the consumer and, ultimately, the business.

Talk to our team today to learn how Escalon can help take your company to the next level.

  • Expertise you can trust

    Our team is made up of seasoned professionals who bring years of industry experience to the table. You gain a trusted advisor who understands your business inside out.

  • Quality and consistency

    Say goodbye to the hassles of hiring, training and managing in-house finance teams. You will never have to worry about unexpected leave of absence or retraining new employees.

  • Scalability and Flexibility

    Whether you’re a small business or a global powerhouse, our solutions scale with your needs. We eliminate inefficiencies, reduce costs and help you focus on growing your business.

Contact Us Today!

Tap into the latest insights from experts in your industry

People Management & HR

2025 Employment Law Updates: What to Know

As we step into 2025, businesses across the country face several important updates in labor laws and employee benefits. Staying...

Read More
Startups

5 Signs Your Startup Needs an Outsourced CFO  

5 Signs Your Startup Needs an Outsourced CFO   Startups often operate with lean teams, but as they grow, financial complexity...

Read More
Leadership & Growth

CG Startups: How to Keep Costs Low While Scaling Operations 

Consumer Goods Startups: How to Keep Costs Low While Scaling Operations  Scaling a consumer goods startup requires a careful balancing...

Read More